LSC/VIRGO Stochastic Analysis Review

Navigation

Review Home
StochReview List/Archive
Stochastic ilog
Stochastic list/Archive
LSCsoft CVS
LSC, LIGO
VIRGO
ALLEGRO

Docs

Conferences 2007
Edit these pages

Review

Overview
Members
Minutes
Status of Reviews

Agenda and Minutes, 12 December 2006

Agenda: Tues, 12 December 2006

I believe the only item on the agenda this time is the latest version of the 
radiometer paper, which is posted at: 

http://www.lsc-group.phys.uwm.edu/sbwg/review/projects.html

This is the same version we considered last week, so you've probably already 
downloaded it.
  

Minutes

+---------------------------------------------------------------------------
| 20061114-minutes.txt - minutes from the Nov 28 Stochastic Review telecon.
|
|  Author        : Warren G. Anderson (warren@gravity.phys.uwm.edu)
|
|  Last Modified : Wed Dec 13 03:00 PM 2006 P
+---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Attending: Warren, Stuart, Robert, Stefan, Harry

Suggestions for Stefan:
- softer first sentence of Abstract
- reference to instrument paper
- do we need to mention that pipeline is coded in matlab?
- various minor wording issues
- use linear scale rather than dB
- correct reference [4]
- remove last line about SCO-X1 in abstract
- DCC document reference for overlapping windows

Update on last weeks request to consult with Periodic group:
- Stefan has emailed Mike Landry
- periodic group has not responded yet
- Stuart suggests going ahead and letting them respond as part of LSC comment
  period.

Overall recommendation of review committee:

We are satisfied with the analysis and presentation and recommend that, after
minor comments above are considered, the paper be put forward for general
LSC-wide review.

Next week:
- people are available so we will have a telecon
- we will consider the promised new draft of L1-A1 paper

Related Email

Subject: Radiometer paper
From: Warren G Anderson 
To: Stochastic List 
CC: Peter Fritschell , 
    Vuk Mandic , 
    Stefan Ballmer , 
    stochreview@gravity.phys.uwm.edu
Date: Today 15:48:27

Hi All,

It is my pleasure to announce on behalf of the Stochastic Review Committee 
that we feel that the S4 radiometer paper is ready to go forward to the LSC 
for general collaboration-wide comment/review. We have given Stefan a short 
list of minor comments/corrections to consider, but we are all pleased with 
the science and the presentation of the current paper. 

I would like to personally offer Stefan congratulations on a job well done.

Warren 
-- 
+================[ WARREN G. ANDERSON ]====================+
| 15 Sierra Vista Terr. SW          (403) 212-1426 HOME    |
| Calgary AB, T3H-3C4, CANADA                              |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| P.O. Box 413,                     (414) 559-5366 US CELL |
| Dept. of Physics                  (414) 229-3323 OFFICE  |
| Milwaukee WI, 53201, USA          (414) 229-5589 FAX     |
+==========================================================+
$Id: 061212.html,v 1.1 2006/12/13 23:50:53 warren Exp $